Magic the Gathering cards have been around for over 20 years! Launched in 1993, they quickly became a popular card game played by approximately 20 million people worldwide.

The combination of an avid fan base and rare items has created the perfect environment for turning Magic Cards into valuable collectibles.

Interested in selling your Magic Cards? Here are the best places to do that, as well as the pro’s and con’s of each:

Collectibles Store

Selling your Magic Cards to a local collectibles store is a great option, if you have a store close by. If they like what you have they will probably offer you cash on the spot in a fairly quick and painless transaction. Unfortunately, you probably won’t get the best price possible by selling to a collectibles store because they need to leave room for their own profit to resell it again.

Pawn Shop

Pawn shops have similar pro’s and con’s to collectibles stores, except there is almost always one close by to find, whereas collectibles stores might be a bit fewer and far between. But like collectibles stores, pawn shops price their items to sell fast, so they will most likely offer you less money for your Magic Cards than anywhere else. It is a quick and all-cash transaction though.


Selling on eBay will usually yield a decent selling price, however the amount of time, effort, money and luck that goes into a successful eBay auction make this a much less attractive option than it may appear to be. Between all the pictures, writing descriptions, paying listing fees, answering questions and then waiting and hoping you find the right buyer, it’s definitely not a good option for everyone.


Similar to eBay, Craigslist is not a very easy method of selling your Magic Cards. And because your listing on Craigslist is somewhat location-dependent, you’ll reach less of an audience of buyers and therefore less likely to yield the best price possible. Again, you may get a decent selling price, but it comes down to a lot of work and a little bit of luck.

Neatstuff Collectibles: The Best Of Both Worlds!

We here at Neatstuff Collectibles spend millions each year buying collectibles like Magic Cards. People choose us because we are the best of both worlds: we make it a very easy transaction and we offer all-cash top-dollar offers if we like what you have.

Interested in selling your Magic Cards to us? Awesome! Give us a call at 800-326-7064 or fill out our seller inquiry form and we will get back to you immediately! If we’re interested in what you have, we will travel to you and potentially make an all-cash offer. Looking forward to hearing from you!

Similar Posts